The rail itself is great and my two year old loves it! He can come and go, but I have the peace of mind that he won't roll out while sleeping. It also looks nice and matches the original crib. I would have given this 5 stars, but where you take off the crib front section - the little pieces to finish off the top molding on the side walls don't match up....really at all. They are much too small. Probably more of a knock on the crib itself, but I had no idea until I installed the rail guard. I would 100% recommend this product as long as that caveat is noted!